Featured Posts

Estimating Tenant Damages - Carpet

October 14, 2015


Carpet damage by tenants is one of the most expensive repairs that a landlord must endure.  How much can a landlord charge a tenant for carpet damage?


We recently had a case where a 1500 s.f. condo had it's 10 year old carpet destroyed by neglectful tenants.  The tenants had resided in the property for only one year.  The carpet was a base grade carpet when new and had a realistic 7-8 year rental lifespan.


The landlord wants the maximum amount withheld from the tenants security deposit.  Here's how we determined the security deposit deduction.


The capet cost about $2,000 new.  It was now the 9 years old when the last tenant moves in.  The tenant destroys what is remaining of the carpet in one year.  We assume:


     The carpet depreciates about 10% per year or $200/ year, assuming normal wear and tear.


     At the start of the 9th year there is only $200 worth of value left in the carpet at move-in.


     The tenants destroy the $200 carpet but also do not perform any tasks required to maintain the

         carpet, i.e. shampoo or vacuum.


     Therefore the charges were $200 for destruction of the remaining carpet and $150 for

        not performing normal maintenance or not preserving the condition of the carpet.  A total of 

        $350 was deducted from the tenant's security deposit.


The landlord was not happy with the decision because the cost to replace the carpet was approximately $2,500.  However, the tenants did not destroy a $2,500 new carpet.  They destroyed a 10 year old rental carpet.


Ultimately, aside from fairness considerations, we must respond to landlord demands by examining how would these deductions be defensible in a court of law if the tenant chose to sue the landlord.  A judge would ask " What method was used to determine the value of the used carpet?" and

"What were the charges to the tenant based on this formula?"


The tenants did not move into a unit with brand new $2,500 carpet.  Because the replacement cost of the carpet cannot be charged to the tenant who lived on 10 year old carpet.

Please reload

Recent Posts

Real Estate Can Boom If Interest Rates Stay Low

August 25, 2014

Please reload

Please reload

Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square
Please reload

  • w-facebook
  • Twitter Clean
  • Google Clean

© 2023 by ​MCDONALD&HARRIS. Proudly created with Wix.com.